Ewen MacAskill in
Ramallah
Friday April 26, 2002
The Guardian
The damage done by the Israeli army during its three-week occupation
of Ramallah, de facto capital of the Palestinian Authority, is
obvious: the flattened cars, blackened buildings and smashed
shopfronts. But the more serious damage is invisible.
The army destroyed or removed the files and records of many
Palestinian ministries and institutions, ranging from high-level
financial documents to the records of school graduations.
The Palestinians were yesterday still clearing up the debris. The
damage is estimated at tens of millions of dollars. Some said it would
take years to rebuild the information that was stolen and taken to
Israel. In many cases, the data has gone forever.
The Palestinians claim that Israel set out to destroy the
infrastructure of their emerging state. The Israeli army insists its
aim was purely to destroy the "infrastructure of terror". An army
spokesman, Lieutenant-Colonel Olivier Rafowicsz, said yesterday: "We
are not in a war against the Palestinian Authority or the Palestinian
people. We are in a war against terrorism."
But the army's interpretation of what constitutes the
"infrastructure of terror" has turned out to be a broad one: the
soldiers trashed schools, banks, hospitals, cultural centres, stores,
human rights offices and radio and television stations, including one
called Peace and Love.
Some of the wreckage was wanton and spiteful, carried out by bored
soldiers billeted in Palestinian buildings.
The looting was small-scale. The worst of the damage was
systematic. Police stations were wrecked and all the Palestinian
Authority's ministries, except the ministry of planning and the
ministry of sport, were ransacked. The main target was computers,
whose hard drives were removed and taken to Israel.
Among the trashed institutions were:
· Aziz Shaheen girls' school
in the But al-Hawa district. With 800 pupils it is one of the
biggest schools on the West Bank, and it has a good academic
reputation, especially in science and technology. Ten Israeli tanks
were parked in its playground for three weeks; snipers used the upper
floor.
Children returning to the school on Monday found it surrounded by
barbed wire, rubbish and spent explosives. They were told by the
principal, Mariam Masharka, 45, to go home until the school was
cleaned up and repaired.
Sabrine Wadir, 15, a pupil, said: "Our first sight was the
playground, surrounded by a barbed-wire fence, as if it was a jail.
The lock to my classroom was broken. They destroyed pictures of
flowers, martyrs, our president."
Musical instruments were looted, books were torn and piled in the
corridors. Anti-Arab graffiti was scrawled in every corridor. Among
the debris was a tapestry in a broken glass frame, saying "Peace and
Justice for Palestine".
An Israeli army spokesman, Captain Ron Edelheit, responded: "If you
have a platoon staying, there are bound to be scratches."
· Mattin human rights group which has an office at a
crossroads on al-Haq street.
Salwa Daibis, a partner in the Mattin group, said: "A metal door
had been flung 50 metres away. It took me half an hour to locate my
desk, upside down, covered with other things, tins of food, Coca-Cola
tins. The cash box was not there.
"I couldn't find my computer. I found a [computer] shell. I think
it is mine. The hard disk is gone. Some monitors are missing. This is
20 years of work. My whole life is there. This is an assault against
an entire population to damage the fabric of society."
Capt Edelheit's response: "The human rights organisations are not
always fair, blonde, blue-eyed Europeans." Some of them were linked to
terrorists, he claimed.
· Housing Bank for Trade and Finance one block from
Manara Square. The headquarters of a Jordanian bank that provides
loans for building homes.
On April 3, a tank fired three rounds through its plate-glass
windows. The entire contents of two floors were demolished.
Talib Muleseh, 45, operations manager for the bank, which has 32
staff, 25,000 customers and is worth $51m, said: "There was no reason
for this. It is banking terror. It is about destroying the Palestinian
infrastructure. The bank supported the Palestinian economy."
He estimated the cost of repairs at more than $200,000, which
includes two new cash-in-the wall machines at $40,000 each.
Capt Edelheit said there were buildings the army had not intended
to attack, but had been forced to after coming under fire: "Where they
fired at us, we fired back."
· Preventative security force's HQ Betunia, west of
Ramallah, was the building most badly battered by Israeli tanks and
rockets.
Before the assault, it resembled a huge hilltop fortress. Now the
compound is gutted, the outside walls black from smoke and punctured
with holes. A fresh Palestinian flag flies from the ruins.
The compound was the headquarters of Colonel Jibril Rajoub, who
heads the most professional of the Palestinian police forces. The
preventative security forces were trained by the CIA, and Mr Rajoub
maintains close contacts with US security officials and with Israel.
The compound was built with CIA cash.
Mr Rajoub, standing amid the rubble from the battle, said: "An
attack of this sort on the preventative security service reflects a
desire to destroy the infrastructure of which preventative security is
the backbone." The Palestinians ask how are they to meet Israel's
demands to arrest militants if their security apparatus is knocked
out.
Capt Edelheit said: "There were 200 armed terrorists inside. Some
of them were policemen and some were terrorists." He added that
policemen during the day sometimes become terrorists at night.
· Puppet theatre in the But al-hawa district.
Soldiers occupied the small theatre used by the puppeteer Nideal al-Khatib,
36, who takes his shows to schools in the West Bank.
"I used the puppets to get across the message that water is
precious. My backdrops were used by the soldiers to cover the
windows," he said, holding the destroyed sheets. "They stole three of
my puppets. They left these two. Maybe they did not like them."
Israel's response: As with the school, some damage is inevitable in
places where soldiers are billeted.
· Land registry office 200 metres east of Manara
Square, holds the deeds to land records on the West Bank. Old pink
maps, with detailed portions of land in faint ink, were scattered
around the floor.
Najiba Suhal, 30, the assistant director, said: "The army destroyed
the entrance to the office and took computers. We are trying to
establish what has been taken. Some of these records go back to the
Turkish era."
Israeli response: No specific information about what happened at
the location.
· Education ministry in north Ramallah The soldiers
took so much material from the ministry that they needed a van to
carry it away.
Salah Sobani, a ministry employee, said that when the Israelis
arrived, "I opened all the doors I had keys for and they blasted the
rest".
Computers were piled in the middle of one floor after being
stripped of hard disks containing a host of information, from
instructions to teachers through to graduation lists.
Dr Gabi Baramki, the authority's adviser on academic affairs, said:
"So much damage in just one hour."
Israeli response: Israel regularly protests that Palestinian
textbooks incite hatred against the Jewish state. "In their computers,
we are trying to find incitement to hate," Capt Edelheit said.
"We are finding glorification of suicide bombers and when we have
the information, we will issue it."
· Peace and Love radio station which has been
broadcasting since 1995 to a target audience of young people. It has a
staff of 25.
Its founder, Mutazb Seiso, 36, said that the station's transmitter,
tapes, mini-disks, mixers and all the other equipment needed to
broadcast had been destroyed. He estimated the cost of the damage at
more than $250,000 and said it would take months to get back on air -
provided there was help from radio stations abroad.
Israeli response: No specific information about this site.